1. Use visual contrast early
Because every answer already belongs to Fairy Tail, the only contrast left is inside the pool: 5 characters, all listed for 2009, where red hair appears on only 1 of them, while black covers 1. Two openers that share a hair colour spend a turn without splitting the board.
2. Let year split smaller pools
Genre is fixed here, so year and eyes carry the load: blue eyes are the rarest tag at 1, and brown the most common at 3. Bracket the era first, then let the remaining visual clue choose between the survivors.
3. Memorize a few anchor characters
A small group of recognizable anchors is enough to carry most solves. For Fairy Tail, useful anchors include Erza Scarlet, Gray Fullbuster, Lucy Heartfilia, Natsu Dragneel because they help you remember distinct clue combinations inside the current pool.