How to use the Fairy Tail answers archive
With 5 characters, all listed for 2009, the Fairy Tail rotation returns to the same faces quickly, so this archive shows the practical order rather than a list of everyone who could appear.
Read it next to the character list and the starting-guesses page: Erza Scarlet and Lucy Heartfilia agree on 4 of the five clue traits, so the rows worth studying are the ones where that pair shows up.